Repair vs Replace a Refrigerator (Canadian Cost Guide)
Refrigerators are the most expensive appliance to replace and the most common to repair. Compressor failure on a unit older than 10 years usually tips the math toward replacement.
AIRepairs Editorial Team
·15+ years combined appliance & HVAC repair experience·Reviewed by Red Seal Certified Technician·| Factor | Repair | Replace |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost (CAD) | $200–$700 | $1,200–$3,500 |
| Compressor replacement | $600–$1,000 | Buy new |
| Lifespan | +3-5 years if under 10 yo | 13-17 years on Energy Star |
| Energy savings | None | $60-$120/yr on newer Energy Star units |
| Best when… | Thermostat, fan, defrost, ice-maker | Compressor + over 10 yrs, or sealed-system leak |
Verdict
Replace any sealed-system failure on a 10+ year old fridge. Repair non-sealed-system parts (fans, thermostats, ice-makers, door seals) at any age.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my fridge running but not cooling?
Most often: dirty condenser coils, failed evaporator fan, or a stuck defrost timer. All three are under $250 to repair.
Is it worth fixing a 15-year-old fridge?
Only if the part is under $200 and easy. After 15 years, energy savings from a new Energy Star unit usually pay back the difference in 4-6 years.